Staff Reporter
HIGH Court judge Claudia Claasen has found Immanuel Venonja, a man accused of stabbing his girlfriend to death, guilty of murder read with the provisions of the Domestic Violence Act.
The state alleges that Venonja, on 31 May 2024, in the district of Otavi, intentionally assaulted Elisabeth Uwu-Khaes by stabbing her in the back with a knife with the intention to kill her. It is alleged that Uwu-Khaes succumbed to her injuries on 1 June 2024 at a medical clinic in Otavi due to hypovolaemic shock caused by the injuries sustained from the stab wound.
Prior to her death, the deceased, Uwu-Khaes, was in a domestic relationship with the accused, as they lived together and also had a child together. Sometime during February 2024, the romantic relationship came to an end, and the deceased left the common household and returned to her mother’s residence.
The state alleges that during the evening of Friday, 31 May 2024, at a local bar in Otavi, the accused, Venonja, approached the deceased and stabbed her in the back with a knife. It is further alleged that when the deceased collapsed, the accused prevented bystanders from taking her to a local healthcare centre. Eventually, the deceased’s brother managed to take her to a medical centre, where she died in the early morning hours of Saturday, 1 June 2024.
Venonja pleaded not guilty to the charge and gave a plea explanation along the lines that the deceased was the aggressor who hit him with an empty beer bottle on his left eyebrow and his ear, which caused him to fall. Furthermore, he claimed that she had a knife in her hand, which he grabbed, and that they started wrestling for possession of the knife. He does not outright say that she stabbed herself in the wrestling, but that is what his version implies.
Judge Claasen stated that the principal issue that presents for determination is whether it was, in fact, Venonja who stabbed the deceased on the night in question.
Giving reasons for the guilty verdict, Claasen explained that the State’s evidence convincingly refutes Venonja’s assertion that he was not in possession of the large knife that night.
“It was not only the eyewitness who observed the accused holding a knife immediately after the stabbing at the bar, but a second witness also saw the accused in possession of the knife at the clinic. Both witnesses described the dark handle and long blade with reasonable accuracy without first being shown the exhibit itself. This strengthens the reliability of their evidence that the accused was in possession of that knife on the night in question,” Claasen said.
She added that the accused’s account provides no coherent explanation of the critical moment at which the fatal wound was inflicted.
“Although he contended that there was a lengthy wrestling for possession of the knife, under the bright light of the door, the court is left in the dark as to whether the alleged wrestling occurred on the ground, following his fall, or while both participants were standing. At best, it constitutes a vague and uncorroborated assertion that withstands neither scrutiny nor comparison with the proven facts,” Claasen said.
She added that the single eyewitness’s account was detailed and clear from the first critical moment onward. He gave a coherent description of the accused’s movements, the way the knife was handled, and the moment it penetrated the deceased’s lower back.
“Having regard to the quality of the observations, the lighting conditions, the witness’s proximity to the incident, and the overall consistency of the single witness, the court is satisfied that his account of the decisive moment is both reliable and credible in all material respects,” Claasen said.
She further stated that there was no innocent account for the presence of the deceased’s blood on the accused’s trousers. The DNA findings in respect of the trousers therefore stand as a cogent piece of incriminating evidence, further linking the accused to the commission of the offence.
Picture for illustrative purposes only. Photo: File


