Select your Top Menu from wp menus
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
Fishrot trial faces continuation challenges as lawyers fully booked for the year

Fishrot trial faces continuation challenges as lawyers fully booked for the year

Staff Reporter

THE Fishrot trial, one of Namibia’s largest fisheries sector corruption cases, is likely to experience further delays after certain lawyers involved in the matter indicated that they may only be available for the continuation of the trial next year.

Lawyer Mbanga Siyomunji, who represents Tamson Hatuikulipi as well as Nigel van Wyk in the matter, indicated that he would only be available for trial continuation next year, specifically in February and April 2025.

Lawyer Florian Beukes, who represents former Fisheries Minister Bernhardt Esau in the matter, indicated that he would be available from 15 January 2025. Meanwhile, Milton Engelbrecht, who represents Mike Nghipunya, Otneel Shuudifonya, and Phillipus Mwapopi, indicated that he would be available from 2 September 2024.

Moving on to the accused persons who are without legal representation, the former attorney general and minister of justice, Sackeus Shanghala, indicated that the trial should only resume in August 2025, as he plans to lodge further applications. Shanghala said that he believes the matter should be placed on a case management roll (returning to a pre-trial phase) before the issues he has raised are determined. This includes challenging the admissibility of evidence from the ACC, which was not empowered at that time by Section 83 of POCA. Additionally, Shanghala is challenging the admissibility of evidence from the state in terms of the International Cooperation in Criminal Matters Act.

James Hatuikulipi suggested that the trial should continue in January 2026, while Pius Mwatelulo proposed that the trial resume in nine months. Ricardo Gustavo indicated that April 2025 would be an appropriate time.

Judge Chinhengo, however, took issue with the lack of availability of some of the lawyers in the matter and expressed sympathy for the accused persons.

“If lawyers are not available, it means matters do not commence… How does the system impact on a speedy trial? With these arrangements, is the right of the accused to have the matter quickly dealt with being respected?” Chinhengo questioned.

He added that he would not be derailed by any further applications brought by the accused and that he would continue with the trial unless interdicted by a court of law.

The judge ordered the lawyers in the matter to make submissions by Wednesday next week on what should happen when a lawyer is not available for a trial date set down by a judge. He postponed the case to 27 August 2024 for a ruling on the continuation of the trial.

During the hearing, the judge also turned down an application for direction in terms of High Court Rule 32, brought forth by Sacky Shanghala in the form of two notices of motion. These notices delved into questions on how to proceed after the judge dismissed the Section 319 application on questions of law, as well as the appropriateness of the Otjozondjupa courtroom to hold the Fishrot trial.

Chinhengo dismissed both notices and indicated that, in terms of advice sought on how to proceed with the Section 319 application, the High Court does not provide legal advice. He further added that the lack of tables, chairs, backrests, and consulting rooms is not a significant issue given their impact on a fair trial. He also added that there is little a judge can do regarding the availability of facilities at a courthouse, as he does not manage such matters.

Related posts